An inspection report from the Mississippi Department of Wildlife, Fisheries and Parks details how some high-fence enclosure and breeding pen owners, including prominent individuals, have violated rules intended to protect the state’s free-ranging deer herd from chronic wasting disease.
Officials observed potential violations at 10 breeding pens, two of which are under the ownership of billionaire brothers Tommy and Jim Duff and another owned by former state wildlife commissioner Billy Deviney. Violations across the breeding pens in potential violation of state law include deer dying without being reported, deer not being accounted for, and improper breeding practices.
The full inspection report for one of the pens was not included in the released materials. Separately, a high-risk finding involving unpermitted semen importation was omitted from the report that was released.
Across the 12 inspected breeding pens, inspectors documented 13 deer that died without CWD samples submitted, at least 53 deer that were untagged, carried faded tags, or bore tags from other enclosures, and more than 160 deer with incorrect, missing, or untraceable records.
Additional findings included breeding pens not listed on permit applications, incomplete commercial enclosure records, deer harvested over the bag limit without required EMAP tags, and a buck skull with the antlers removed inside a pen whose inventory listed only does. Only two pens had no issues, with all records in order and deer accounted for.
What stood out the most, though, is that some of the properties involve powerful individuals in Mississippi’s political and outdoor spaces. The initial public records request for the inspection report was filed by Ricky Mathews of SuperTalk Outdoors. Additional information on the omitted pen report has been requested by SuperTalk Mississippi News.
Duff enclosure
The Duff brothers built Southern Tire Mart into North America’s largest commercial truck-tire dealer. Tommy Duff is also widely discussed as a potential Republican candidate for governor in 2027. According to the inspection report, the Duff property (labeled by MDWFP as SE48, Black Creek 2), a 320-acre site in Lamar County, was inspected on April 23, 2026. Its status was listed as “Administrative Quarantine.”
The report states that there was no harvest data for the 2025-26 season for this specific enclosure. Five deer died within the breeding pens in the same season. Of those five, three were not submitted for CWD sampling. Three untagged deer were in the breeding pens. 19 deer had incorrect records: either no previous records from the previous year, or the records did not match the past two permit years, or there were no acquisition, birth, or release dates. The report notes that the facts surrounding these possible violations are under investigation.
The most significant issue involving the Duff pen was not included in the report released to the requester. It was later discovered from a tip that the pen had been placed under administrative quarantine after the discovery of unpermitted semen importation.
Under MDWFP rules, administrative quarantine can be imposed on an enclosure while an investigation is ongoing if the enclosure is suspected of violating applicable laws or rules. The automatic long-term quarantine and depopulation provisions in the rule are triggered by unlawful importation of live white-tailed deer.
Allegedly, the unpermitted semen crossed state lines illegally and was then implanted in a doe. This raises CWD concerns. A 2019 research study showed that CWD prions can be present in the semen of infected white-tailed deer bucks. Studies are underway to determine whether the levels found in semen are sufficient to transmit the disease through artificial insemination; until those results are complete, caution is advised.
Mississippi’s semen permitting approach recognizes this risk by requiring prior approval and source traceability before importation. Whether the semen was traced to one or more CWD-positive sources, and whether any fawns were produced from it, remains an open question.
In written answers to follow-up questions, the department stated that deficiencies have been corrected, permits approved, and quarantines lifted. When asked for the current status of investigations and any citations for enclosures listed as under investigation, it answered: “Investigation ongoing and citations have been or will be issued. Any references to citations issued or their status would be improper for the MDWFP to disclose at this time.”
Administrative quarantine is available while an investigation is ongoing. Lifting the quarantine while continuing to describe the investigation as open creates a direct contradiction, according to department guidelines.
The department’s refusal to disclose citation status rests on the Mississippi Public Records Act’s treatment of investigative records. The law permits agencies to withhold records related to an open investigation. That exemption, as applied here by the department’s law enforcement bureau, has the practical effect of allowing basic status information to remain undisclosed for as long as the agency asserts that an investigation is ongoing.
Duff’s camp declined to comment on the investigation when this story was published.
Deviney enclosure
Deviney. served on the Mississippi Commission on Wildlife, Fisheries, and Parks for roughly 14 years during the period when the state’s high-fence enclosure and breeding-pen rules were developed and implemented. He has continued to advocate for the industry.
In 2022, he notably appeared before the wildlife commission on behalf of enclosure and breeding-facility owners seeking authority for them to buy and sell captive-bred deer.
His property (SW01, Deviney Enclosure) is 1,012 acres in Copiah County. It was inspected on May 7, 2026. Its status was listed as “Conditional.”
The report states that “three deer died in a breeding pen/after release into a larger enclosure and did not get submitted for CWD sampling. 9 deer couldn’t be accounted for due to tags fading. 2 untagged mature bucks in the breeding pens with no evidence a tag was ever present. 2 untagged fawns in alleyway of breeding facility.”
The report added that “12 deer are in BP but no previous records of them. 2 deer were present in BP inspection but says released into large enclosure. 97 deer unaccounted for in breeder pens that were on BP records for last year. Of those 97, 14 say they were moved to another BP but were not present during our inspection.”
The report notes that the investigation is ongoing and that charges are forthcoming.
The facility has reportedly sold commercial hunts in the past. It held no commercial hunting permit in 2025 or 2026 and no permits of any kind in 2026 at the time of the inspection, the report showed. State law requires commercial hunting operations to report the hunter’s name, license number, date, and harvest. Whether the enclosure conducted any commercial hunting activity in the last two years without the required permit remains an open question.
After additional questions about the breeding pen, the department answered: “After investigation, it was found that most of the deer had been moved from the breeding pen to the larger enclosure and some had died. The Department will continue to require accurate records on deer movement. The appropriate citations have been issued. In the end, it was determined that there were not, in fact, 97 deer unaccounted for.”
Deviney’s camp had not responded to a request for comment by the time of publication.
Last week, SuperTalk Mississippi News sent a public records request asking for all reconciliation records.
Former deer program coordinator weighs in
Wildlife consultant Lann Wilf, the former head of MDWFP’s deer program and host of the YouTube channel Old Biologist, noted the disparity before it was known that the semen issues had not been disclosed.
“Why did SE48 (Duff Enclosure) have an administrative quarantine with the 19 incorrect records, three dead breeding pen deer with no samples, and three untagged deer, while SW01 (Deviney) had 97 discrepancies, 12 with no records, 14 vanished, two fawns of unknown origin, two bucks of unknown origin, and three CWD samples unaccounted for and no quarantine?” Wilf inquired. “This makes no sense and is not logical. Quarantine is a big deal. Something has to be amiss.”
Wilf added that, based on his experience inside MDWFP under a previous administration, he witnessed “multiple instances where individuals connected politically or who are wealthy received inconsistent enforcement of the law related to enclosure regulations, deer escapes from enclosures, and reproductive material importation. These inconsistencies are a significant part of why I changed employment in 2015,” he said.
Legal and policy questions
Unpermitted semen importation to a property could raise questions under the federal Lacey Act, which prohibits the interstate movement or sale of wildlife or parts taken, possessed, or sold in violation of state law. Separately, if any enclosure conducts commercial hunting without the required state permit and any deer taken during that activity are transported across state lines, that can also raise Lacey Act questions. The department has not addressed whether either issue was evaluated under that statute.
This newsroom also reached out to see if the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service happened to be involved in the state investigations. MDWFP had not answered that question by the time of publication.
Last week, while these inspection issues were already the subject of reporting, representatives of breeders and high-fenced enclosure owners met with MDWFP representatives at the Butler Snow office in Jackson. They advanced a legislative agenda that includes reducing CWD testing requirements, among other items.
What MDWFP said
While MDWFP officials had not responded to all records requests, the agency’s executive director, Lynn Posey, acknowledged Wilf’s remarks but did not opine on them. He did, however, speak to the nature of active investigations. Posey, elaborating on the inspection process, said MDWFP personnel and landowners work together on strategies to remedy deficiencies when they are caught.
If the landowner or manager is not willing to comply with the state, the individual is subject to criminal penalties, Posey said. This system, per MDWFP, applies evenly to all Mississippi landowners.
“I respect that former employees may hold their own views. I cannot speak about Mr. Wilf’s personal opinions as he left the employ of the agency over a decade ago, prior to my becoming executive director,” Posey said.
“MDWFP takes questions about the consistent application of deer-enclosure rules seriously. High-fenced enclosures are subject to inspection. When a deficiency is identified, staff and the enclosure operator work together to develop a plan to address it. That process does not change the operator’s responsibility to follow the rules, and resorting to the criminal justice system may be appropriate depending on the circumstances.”
Posey noted that each investigation is independent. The agency, according to him, handles each case individually, and assesses each landowner or manager’s response to potential violations of state law.
“Facility inspections are handled on a case-by-case basis. Every inspection is shaped by the facts at the time: current rules and guidelines, what staff observed, which requirements applied, and whether a deficiency was corrected,” Posey said. “The number of visits alone does not explain why one situation resulted in a citation, and another did not.”
As it pertains to breeder-pen inspections, Posey said rules have evolved over the years, and he expects that trend to continue, especially with CWD posing a threat to the state’s deer populations. He added that there could be more rule revisions as early as January, when the state’s wildlife commission meets.
“Since the establishment of a structured permitting and inspection system for deer enclosures in 2008, requirements have been revised multiple times over the years as the state has addressed the evolving program, especially with the presence of chronic wasting disease,” Posey said.
“The agency has been reviewing the current rules, including inspection and enforcement records, and the circumstances behind each decision. We will use that to inform our ongoing evaluation and amendment of enclosure rules set to be proposed as early as January’s commission meeting.”
“Our goal is to conserve and enhance Mississippi’s wildlife for generations to come, and we appreciate your efforts in learning more about our processes,” Posey told this newsroom.
What’s at stake
CWD is a fatal, highly contagious disease among white-tailed deer that can persist in the environment. Captive breeding facilities and high-fence enclosures create pathways for disease introduction and concentration that do not exist in free-ranging herds. Since it was first detected in Mississippi in 2018, 584 confirmed cases have been found across 18 counties.
The inspection report and the department’s subsequent answers leave material gaps on facilities tied to influential operators. Incomplete reporting, an alleged omitted potential high-risk finding, a lifted quarantine alongside continued claims that the investigation remains open, and industry pressure to reduce testing requirements could leave the public unable to evaluate whether CWD pathways are actually being monitored.
White-tailed deer hunting generates more than $1 billion in economic activity for Mississippi each year, according to a recent study by the Mississippi State University Deer Lab. That economic contribution, along with the cultural and ecological value of the free-ranging herd, is what is placed at risk when high-fenced breeding operations introduce CWD pathways that do not exist in the wild.
“They are playing Russian Roulette with our natural resource,” Wilf concluded.



